Grilled Honey Mustard Chicken

This grilled honey mustard chicken recipe will be your new favorite easy dinner and meal prep! Healthy grilled chicken tenders that go perfectly on their own, on a salad, or even in a wrap!

Turn on your grill and get ready to make the best grilled chicken of your life today! This super easy grilled honey mustard chicken recipe is a staple in our house, and it’s going to be a staple in yours, too.

But let’s back up…

Is it hard to grill chicken?

Are you like me and was once afraid to use any other method other than baking chicken because you didn’t know how to use a grill? Yep, I’ve been there. I used to think grilling was just for men and would have to beg my dad or boyfriend to go on and grill for me.

In our house, my mom was in charge of the inside kitchen work while my dad did all the grilling, and I don’t think I’m alone in this regard. Grills have a manly reputation, it almost comes naturally for us to just assume that men do all the grill work!

Well, this honey mustard chicken recipe is going to prove that wrong. It’s a healthier twist on a traditional easy honey mustard chicken recipe, free of refined sugar and preservatives.

What kind of chicken is best for grilling?

Any kind! Seriously, we grill chicken tenders for this recipe, but you can also grill chicken breasts, chicken legs, or chicken thighs! They all will be delicious for this recipe, you may just need to adjust the cooking time.

All of our chicken is from ButcherBox, which is a company that specializes in 100% grass-fed, grass-finished beef, heritage breed pork, and free-range organic chicken. We LOVE it because you can select whatever type of meat you want, whatever CUT of meat you want, and its all top quality.

Here’s how ButcherBox works:

1. Choose from curated mixes of high quality beef, chicken, or pork – or customize your own.
2. Receive all your meat in an insulated box, solid and packaged with care.
3. Done. Delivered right to your door!

ButcherBox has a goal to make high-quality meat accessible to as many people as possible. By partnering with a collective of small farms, they are able to deliver you the best products for less than $6 per meal. And shipping is free! Use this link for $35 off your first order.

How to make grilled honey mustard chicken

It is seriously easy to make grilled honey mustard chicken, trust me on that one. All you need to do is follow the simple steps below and you’ll be ready to make the best grilled chicken ever.

1. Marinate the chicken

This step is completely optional, but we like to do it. You won’t be marinating the chicken in the honey mustard sauce because since honey is quick to burn, we don’t put the sauce on until after the chicken has been almost grilled all the way through.

In a ziplock bag or a bowl, you’ll mix olive oil, salt, and garlic together and mix it in with the chicken. Let this sit while for one hour and prepare the sauce while you wait.

2. Make honey mustard sauce

In a small bowl, mix together the dijon or spicy brown mustard (either will work here!) with honey, olive oil, and a pinch of salt and pepper. This will serve as your honey mustard sauce that you will brush on the chicken after it has cooked most of the way through.

Save half the sauce for dipping and drizzling later!

3. Grill the chicken

Turn the grill up to 425 degrees and once hot, place your chicken tenders directly on it. These chicken tenders don’t have any sauce on them yet, so you will essentially be grilling them naked.

*You can grill them with the sauce directly on them right away, just be aware that the sugar crystals in the honey will burn and leave a deep char.

Grill the tenders for three minutes and then flip. Once you have flipped them for the first time, brush with a hefty dose of honey mustard sauce. Close the lid and let them grill for another 3 minutes.

After three minutes are up, flip back over again and brush the other side with honey mustard sauce. Close the lid and grill for two minutes.

Flip one more time to get grill marks on both sides (thanks to the sugar crystals in the honey burning, causing a nice char). Remove tenders once internal temperature reaches 165F, about 8-10 minutes total.

How to serve grilled honey mustard chicken

We served this with some grilled sweet potatoes and roasted broccoli, with half of the sauce that we saved on the side for dipping!

This grilled honey mustard chicken made the best meal prep for the week, too. We packed it up with some quinoa and veggies and ate it for lunch all week!

It would also go great in a wrap or even on a sandwich. The options are endless.

If you make this recipe, be sure to comment below and let me know how it was! Also tag @erinliveswhole on Instagram and use the hashtag #erinliveswhole so I can see it and feature you!

If you liked this recipe, you’ll want to try these!

• Grilled Chicken Fajitas
• One Pan Honey Mustard Chicken
• Baked Chicken Tenders